The contenders:
Andy Yorke - Simple
Bitter:Sweet - Drama
Calexico - Carried To Dust
Coldplay - Viva La Vida or Death And All His Friends
Death Cab For Cutie - Narrow Stairs
The Features - Some Kind Of Salvation
Fleet Foxes - Fleet Foxes
Goldfrapp - Seventh Tree
Islands - Arm's Way
Kraak & Smaak - Plastic People
Ladytron - Velocifero
M83 - Saturdays=Youth
The Notwist - The Devil, You + Me
Okkervil River - The Stand Ins
Old 97's - Blame It On Gravity
Portishead - Third
The Presets - Apocalypso
Ryan Adams & The Cardinals - Cardinology
School Of Seven Bells - Alpinisms
Sigur Rós - Með Suð Í Eyrum Við Spilum Endalaust
Supergrass - Diamond Hoo Ha
All solid albums in their own right. My top 5 are (in no order but alphabetical by artist):
Death Cab For Cutie - Narrow Stairs
I have no doubt in my mind that this is Death Cab's best album to date...more sonically daring than any other that preceded it, Narrow Stairs has a sprawling, atmospheric tone set by the dreamy, room-filling echoing of the pounding opener "Bixby Canyon Bridge" and the positively entrancing "I Will Possess Your Heart", which utilizes a repetitive crescendoing beat that has no equal in DCFC's back catalogue. A personal highlight for me is the powerful "You Can Do Better Than Me", a short track that calls to mind the best of The Beach Boys' Pet Sounds. That's high praise.
Goldfrapp - Seventh Tree
2008's "Seventh Tree" feels like a classic album that's 30 years late in arriving, and I mean that in the best possible way. Alison Goldfrapp's full vocal capabilities are on display here, with each track receiving a different but equally compelling treatment. From the angelic breathiness of the opening "Clowns" to the oddly sardonic "Happiness" to the juxtaposition of high and low in the mid-tempo "Cologne Cerrone Houdini", there isn't a singing style that Goldfrapp doesn't conquer here. The music is equally beautiful, full of sweeping grandiose strings and real modern punch, Seventh Tree is not just one of the best albums of 2008, but one of the best albums of modern pop history.
M83 - Saturdays=Youth
In the past, M83 has bounced between producing loosely coordinated electronic noise and powerful cohesive post-rock, and there have been many gems from that approach. Saturdays=Youth is the first time that M83 has made an album that's truly compelling and listenable from beginning to end, however, combining catchy pop hooks with a sound that's as otherwordly and driving as the most obtuse of their previous works. The variety here is beyond reproach and even somewhat surprising, from the radio-friendly Kim & Jessie to the uniquely danceable Couleurs and everything in between...M83 is out there making a sound that nobody else is making.
Okkervil River - The Stand Ins
The continuation of last year's (even better) "The Stage Names", The Stand Ins shows just how mature Okkervil River has become in just a few years. Lyrically above reproach, weaving complex and verbose stories in and out through multiple tracks with undeniably poetic pacing and language, The Stand Ins also crafts pop rock sounds with unique instrumentation to back up its lyrical prowess.
School Of Seven Bells - Alpinisms
Every once in awhile you get an album and realize that it's actually a totally fresh sound. That is Alpinisms. Broadly ambitious, and though not always 100% successful, uniquely compelling, Alpinisms matches electronic dancehall beats to actual instrumentation and is backed by a wall of vocal harmonies that tie everything together. Unlike glitch music, Alpinisms flows calmly but steadily like a river, carrying the listener serenely down its course with plenty of interesting sights and sounds along the way.